The 3 Best Types of Roofing Shingles: Pros, Cons, and Expert Recommendations
February 8, 2025
Hey there, roofing enthusiasts! Ever found yourself pondering, “What is the difference between roof sheathing and roof decking?” You’re not alone! Today, we’re diving deep into this question that has left many of us scratching our heads. Grab your favorite brew, settle in, and let’s demystify these terms together!
1. Setting The Stage: The World Above Our Heads
If you’re anything like me, you’ve probably spent a decent amount of time looking up at roofs, wondering about their complexities. Beneath those shingles or tiles, there’s a world of structure and intricacy. A big part of that world? Roof sheathing and roof decking.
2. Understanding Roof Sheathing: The Unsung Hero
When we think about a roof, we often envision the external layer. However, roof sheathing is the hidden MVP.
What is Roof Sheathing?
- Definition: Roof sheathing is the board layer placed directly on top of roof trusses or rafters. It provides a stable foundation for the roofing materials.
Common Materials:
- Oriented Strand Board (OSB): A favorite in the construction world, OSB is made of interwoven wood strands combined with adhesive. It’s like the multi-grain bread of roofing — layered, sturdy, and reliable.
- Plywood: Another crowd-pleaser, plywood offers a beautiful balance between strength and weight.
Roles it Plays:
- Stability Provider: Roof sheathing offers rigidity, preventing sagging or bending.
- Weather’s Worst Enemy: It’s an added layer of protection against Mother Nature’s tantrums.
- A Reliable Foundation: It serves as the base for roofing materials like shingles or tiles.
3. Roof Decking Decoded: More Than Just a Fancy Term
Now, onto the term that often gets intertwined with sheathing — roof decking. While the two share similarities, they’re distinct in their own right.
Decking Defined:
- Definition: Roof decking is a broader term that represents the foundational surface upon which roofing materials are applied.
The Subtle Distinctions:
- Material Spectrum: Beyond the common plywood or OSB, roof decking might involve concrete, metal, or other specialized materials, particularly in commercial setups.
- Positioning: While roof sheathing is directly atop the structural components, decking could be part of an elevated layer in certain roofing systems.
4. The Big Question: How Often Should Roof Sheathing Be Replaced?
Since we’re diving deep, it’s crucial to address another pressing query: “How often should roof sheathing be replaced?”. A question that’s both important and practical.
Signs It’s Time:
- The Sagging Dance: Noticeable droops or sags between rafters are a big red flag.
- Water’s Mark: Dark spots or mold signify water damage, and that’s never good.
- Time’s Toll: Generally, if your roof’s age is pushing 25-30 years, it’s wise to check the sheathing.
- Re-roofing Moments: If you’re updating your roof, it’s the perfect time to assess and possibly replace the sheathing.
5. Roof Sheathing and Roof Decking: A Harmonious Duo
Yes, they’re different. But roof sheathing and roof decking also complement each other beautifully. It’s like peanut butter and jelly, or Netflix and chill – better together!
- Sheathing Strength: Provides the primary support.
- Decking Dynamics: Adds depth, layers, and sometimes additional fortitude.
6. Why All This Matters?
In our quest to understand roof sheathing and roof decking, we’ve unearthed more than just definitions. We’ve discovered the passion, precision, and care that goes into every square foot above our heads. And if you’re a homeowner or planning to be one, this knowledge isn’t just empowering — it’s essential.
7. Wrapping Up: The Sky’s the Limit!
So, there you have it, my roofing-savvy friend! We’ve tackled the mystery of “What is the difference between roof sheathing and roof decking?”, unraveled nuances, and shared some laughs along the way.
I genuinely hope this guide not only clarifies terms but also sparks an appreciation.
FAQs
What are the other roofing materials that make up a roof?
A roof is comprised of several materials that work together to protect your home and ensure its structural integrity. Aside from roof decking, which we have already covered, there are other crucial components you should be aware of when it comes to your roof replacement. One important material is the underlayment. This layer is installed directly onto the roof decking and acts as a secondary barrier against moisture. It provides added protection in case any water manages to penetrate the outer layer of your roof. Another essential component is the roof shingles. Shingles are the visible, outermost layer of your roof. They come in various materials such as asphalt, clay, metal, wood, or slate.
Shingles not only provide aesthetic appeal, but they also serve as a protective layer against the elements, including rain, snow, and wind. Flashings are also crucial roofing materials. These are thin strips of metal, typically made of aluminum or galvanized steel, that are installed around roof penetrations, such as chimneys, skylights, and vents. Flashings prevent water from seeping into these vulnerable areas and ensure a watertight seal. Ventilation components are vital as well. These include ridge vents, soffit vents, and attic fans. Proper ventilation helps regulate the temperature and humidity levels in the attic, preventing moisture buildup and reducing the risk of mold and ice dam formation.
Roofing nails are yet another material that plays a significant role. These nails are specifically designed for roofing applications and are used to secure the shingles to the roof decking. Using the right type and size of nails ensures the shingles remain securely fastened, even during severe weather conditions. Additionally, drip edge is an important roofing material that helps direct water away from the edge of the roof. It prevents water from seeping into the underlying structures, such as the fascia board, and protects against potential water damage.
Lastly, ridge caps are installed along the ridges of the roof to provide extra protection and create a finished look. These specialized shingles or metal caps cover the exposed ends of the roof’s peak and help seal any gaps, preventing water infiltration. Understanding these various roofing materials gives you a comprehensive view of what goes into a roof replacement or repair project. By being informed about these components, you can make better decisions regarding your roof’s maintenance, longevity, and overall protection.
What are the codes related to roof decking?
When it comes to roof decking, there are specific codes that need to be followed for proper installation. As per the 2018 International Residential Code (R905.2.1), asphalt shingles should be fastened to solidly sheathed decks. Essentially, this means that the roof decking, also known as roof sheathing, must be strong enough to support and hold the new roof materials when they are installed. If there is any rotten or deteriorating decking, or if the existing decking cannot withstand the weight of the new roofing materials, it must be replaced in accordance with the codes.
It is important to adhere to the manufacturer’s installation instructions, as there is a separate code that states roofing contractors must follow these instructions provided by the shingle manufacturer. An additional code to consider, starting from 2021, is related to plank decking. If there is more than an 1/8-inch gap between the planks, the roof decking must be replaced according to the shingle manufacturer’s installation instructions before the roofing materials can be nailed on. It is worth noting that some roofing contractors may choose to overlook this requirement in order to offer lower prices and undercut the competition. However, it is important to prioritize the proper installation of the roof decking to ensure the longevity and stability of the roofing system.
How much does roof decking cost?
The cost of roof decking can vary due to the fluctuation of wood prices. In 2024, wood prices have significantly increased, which can add a considerable expense to your roof investment if a substantial amount of decking needs to be replaced. While it is challenging to provide exact prices or a specific price range, I can offer a general idea of the relative costs associated with different types of decking. Plank decking is typically priced on a per linear foot basis, while sheet decking is priced per sheet.
When factoring in labor and materials, plank decking generally costs about three times more per square foot compared to sheet decking. Therefore, if you have a significant amount of plank decking that requires replacement, it may be more cost-effective to overlay the existing plank decking with OSB 7/16” or 3/8” CDX plywood. Ultimately, the precise cost of your roof decking can only be determined by your roofing contractor after assessing the specific type and quantity of decking that needs to be replaced.
What are the types of wood roof decking?
Wood roof decking refers to the wooden boards that form the framework of a roof and provide a base for installation of roofing materials, such as shingles. There are two main types of wood roof decking: plank decking and sheet decking. Plank decking, which was commonly used before the advent of plywood, consists of elongated and rectangular wooden boards. These boards typically come in two sizes, 1×6 or 1×8. Although plank decking is not as widely used nowadays, it can still be found on roofs. Sheet decking, as the name suggests, is composed of flat sheets of wood. There are two types of sheet decking: plywood and OSB (oriented strand board). OSB is the more prevalent type of sheet decking in modern construction.
It is made by compressing wood chips or strips into a flat sheet with a thickness of 7/16″. Plywood, on the other hand, is available in several thicknesses, ranging from ¼” to ¾”, depending on the span of the rafters. While OSB is the more commonly used sheet decking material, plywood continues to be utilized in residential roofing. The choice between the two types of sheet decking ultimately depends on factors such as budget and availability of the wood. Both options can effectively serve as a solid base for roofing components and provide structural support.
When should roof decking be replaced?
1. What are some signs that indicate it’s time to replace roof sheathing?
Signs that it may be time to replace roof sheathing include noticeable droops or sags between rafters, dark spots or mold indicating water damage, and if you’re updating your roof, it’s a good opportunity to assess and possibly replace the sheathing.
2. How often should roof sheathing be replaced?
The frequency of roof sheathing replacement depends on various factors. However, it is recommended to check the sheathing if the roof’s age is pushing 25-30 years.
3. What happens if the decking’s integrity is sound?
If the contractor finds that the integrity of the decking is sound, it means that it can handle the installation of the new asphalt roof.
4. What should be done if rotten boards are found in the decking?
If rotten boards are found during the roof replacement process, the roofing contractor has to replace the decking before they can begin installing the new roofing components.
5. How much of the roof decking needs to be replaced?
The exact extent of roof decking replacement can only be determined after tearing off the old roof. Usually, there are going to be a few boards that have to be changed out.
Thanks for joining me on this journey! If you found this enlightening, share it with a fellow roofing enthusiast. And remember, keep looking up, because every roof has a story.
Stay curious and keep roofing!
Recent Comments