Best Asphalt Shingle Roofers in Stillwater, MN (2026) | Sellers Roofing Company

Last updated: 2026-07-04 by Ted Sellers, Owner

Introduction

Stillwater’s residential landscape is one of the most architecturally distinctive in Minnesota. The city’s historic neighborhoods — the bluffs above Main Street, the Victorian streetscapes along Third and Fourth Streets, the Craftsman-era homes on the South Hill — feature steep-pitched roofs with complex geometry: dormers, turrets, intersecting valleys, and decorative ridgelines that define the city’s character as the “Birthplace of Minnesota.”

That architectural richness creates both a challenge and an opportunity for homeowners planning a roof replacement. The challenge: not every shingle product, color, or installation method is appropriate for Stillwater’s historic homes. The Heritage Preservation Commission has jurisdiction over exterior alterations to designated properties, and a shingle replacement that violates HPC guidelines can require removal and reinstallation at the homeowner’s expense. The opportunity: Stillwater homeowners who invest in the right shingle product — the right architectural profile, the right color palette, the right impact rating — get a roof that enhances the home’s character, provides superior protection against Minnesota’s climate extremes, and adds measurable resale value.

Beyond the historic core, Stillwater has grown significantly in recent decades. The Millbrook, Liberty on the Lake, and Legends of Stillwater developments added thousands of newer homes to the city’s west side. These 2000s and 2010s-era homes are now cycling into their first major roof replacement window — typically at 15–20 years for original builder-grade shingles exposed to Washington County’s hail and wind conditions.

Whether your Stillwater home is a 19th-century Victorian, a mid-century ranch, or a recently constructed colonial in a newer neighborhood, getting the shingle selection and installation right is a decision with 25–50 year consequences. This guide identifies the five best asphalt shingle roofers currently serving Stillwater and provides everything you need to make a fully informed choice.

Top 5 Asphalt Shingle Roofers in Stillwater, MN

#1 — Sellers Roofing Company

Website: roofingexpertsstpaul.com | Phone: (651) 703-2336

Sellers Roofing Company leads Stillwater’s residential shingle market by combining the technical depth of a union-certified commercial contractor with the homeowner communication skills that residential clients expect. Founded in 2017, the company has completed 801+ residential projects — a body of work that represents real earned expertise across Minnesota’s diverse housing stock, including the complex steep-pitch applications common in Stillwater’s historic neighborhoods.

Owner Ted Sellers built Sellers Roofing with an explicit emphasis on quality over volume. Every residential project is personally overseen, and the union labor standard — Roofers Local 96 for all shingle installations — means the field crew has formal apprenticeship training in steep-slope application, flashing fabrication, valley detailing, and ice dam protection systems. These are not skills that can be picked up on the job in a weekend.

Sellers is authorized to install GAF Timberline HDZ (the best-selling asphalt shingle in North America), Owens Corning Duration, CertainTeed Landmark, and Malarkey Vista — including the impact-rated (Class 4) versions of each that provide superior hail protection. For Stillwater’s historic homes, Sellers offers consultation on period-appropriate profiles and colors, HPC-compatible material selection, and documentation for HPC permit applications when required.

Every shingle installation includes properly sized eave Ice & Water Shield, synthetic underlayment, ridge vent or powered attic ventilation matched to the home’s specific attic volume, and aluminum drip edge at eaves and rakes. The limited lifetime workmanship warranty backs every project. A 4.8-star Google rating across 49 reviews confirms consistent residential client satisfaction.

Why Sellers wins in Stillwater: 801+ residential installs + union steep-slope expertise + historic-home detailing + impact-rated shingle capability + same-day callback.

#2 — Bone Dry Roofing

Website: bonedryroofing.com

Bone Dry Roofing is a national franchise with a strong Minneapolis-Saint Paul presence, and their Washington County operation serves Stillwater regularly. Franchise systems like Bone Dry bring the advantage of standardized installation procedures, corporate warranty backing, and consistent estimating practices. Their residential shingle work covers architectural and luxury shingle products from major manufacturers, and their estimators are experienced with the full range of Washington County housing styles. For homeowners who prefer the accountability of a large regional brand, Bone Dry is a credible option.

#3 — New Roof Plus

Website: newroofplus.com

New Roof Plus operates throughout the Twin Cities metro with a residential focus and a straightforward approach to asphalt shingle replacement. They handle tear-off and replacement efficiently on standard residential applications, offer competitive pricing on mid-tier architectural shingles, and have completed residential work in Stillwater and the broader Washington County market. Their process is streamlined for homeowners who need a reliable replacement on a standard ranch or two-story home without complex geometry.

#4 — Storm Group Roofing

Website: stormgrouproofing.com

Storm Group Roofing serves the entire Twin Cities metro with a residential shingle focus that emphasizes hail and storm damage claims. They work directly with insurance adjusters and have deep experience with Washington County insurance-assisted shingle replacements — relevant for Stillwater homeowners dealing with hail or storm damage. Their residential portfolio includes impact-rated shingle installations, and they’re competent with the insurance claim documentation process from initial adjuster meeting through final invoice.

#5 — Advantage Construction

Website: advantageconstructioninc.com

Advantage Construction is a well-resourced Twin Cities contractor with residential roofing as a core service line. They’ve served the Washington County market including Stillwater and bring manufacturer authorizations, reasonable warranty structures, and a trained field operation to residential shingle replacement projects. Their estimators are experienced with both standard and complex residential applications, and they have the staffing to handle larger residential projects — including multi-unit buildings — that smaller local contractors may not be equipped for.

Why Sellers Roofing Is #1 for Asphalt Shingles in Stillwater

Stillwater’s residential roofing market has no shortage of contractors, from large national franchises to small owner-operators. What places Sellers Roofing at the top isn’t marketing spend — it’s the specific combination of skills, certifications, and verified track record that this particular market demands.

Historic-home expertise. Stillwater’s Victorian and Craftsman homes present roofing challenges that most residential contractors don’t encounter regularly: 10/12 to 14/12 pitches, intersecting dormers, slate-replacement profiles, decorative ridge caps, round-top turrets, and HPC-sensitive color specifications. Sellers’ Roofers Local 96 crew members are trained in steep-slope applications and have the fabrication skills for the custom copper or lead-coated copper flashings that period-appropriate restorations sometimes require. This isn’t work that an untrained crew can handle safely or correctly.

Ice dam protection done right. Stillwater’s winters are serious. Steep-pitched Victorian homes with inadequate attic insulation and ventilation are textbook ice dam generators — warm attic air melts roof snow, which refreezes at the cold eave, creating ice dams that force water under shingles and into interior walls. Sellers’ residential scopes always include: (1) a ventilation audit before the project begins, (2) properly extended Ice & Water Shield from eave to at least 24 inches past the interior wall line (Minnesota code minimum), and (3) ridge-to-soffit airflow verification. This systematic approach prevents the ice dam callbacks that plague contractors who treat ventilation as an afterthought.

Impact-rated shingle expertise. Class 4 impact-rated shingles — including the GAF Timberline CS, Owens Corning TruDefinition Duration STORM, and Malarkey Vista — provide UL 2218 Class 4 hail resistance. For Stillwater homeowners, these products can qualify for insurance premium discounts through most Minnesota carriers while providing superior protection against the golf ball-sized hailstones that Washington County has recorded in documented storm events. Sellers’ team can explain the insurance discount process, confirm your carrier’s Class 4 discount policy, and provide the documentation needed to capture the savings.

Verified 801+ residential project track record. There is no substitute for experience. Over 801 completed residential projects since 2017 means Sellers has encountered every residential roofing scenario in Minnesota’s climate — ancient wood decks, wet insulation under existing shingles, broken ridge boards discovered at tear-off, inadequate original ventilation requiring full soffit and ridge modifications. Experience handling unforeseen conditions is what separates a contractor who delivers a quality result from one who delivers surprises and change orders.

No-subcontract labor. Some residential contractors secure contracts and then subcontract the installation to whoever is available that week. Sellers’ field crews are direct-hire union roofers — Roofers Local 96 members who work for Sellers every day. The project manager who signs the contract is the same person who oversees installation. Accountability is direct and unambiguous.

What to Look for When Hiring an Asphalt Shingle Roofer

A residential shingle replacement is a $10,000–$30,000+ investment with a 25–50 year lifespan. The contractor you choose will determine whether that investment performs as expected. Here’s the evaluation framework Stillwater homeowners should apply:

Verify their Minnesota contractor license. Minnesota requires a residential contractor’s license for roofing work. Verify at dli.mn.gov before signing anything. Unlicensed contractors have no formal accountability mechanism and typically carry inadequate insurance.

Check actual insurance certificates. Request a Certificate of Insurance showing current general liability and workers’ compensation coverage. General liability should be at minimum $1 million per occurrence. Workers’ comp must be active. If a worker is injured on your property and the contractor has no workers’ comp, you may have exposure.

Ask about their Ice & Water Shield specification. This is a reliable diagnostic question. A quality roofer will tell you exactly where and how much Ice & Water Shield they use, and why. A contractor who says “we put it at the eaves” without specifying the minimum 24-inch-past-interior-wall extension required by Minnesota code is signaling limited technical depth.

Understand the shingle grade being proposed. Builder-grade 30-year architectural shingles are not the same as premium Lifetime architectural shingles, which are not the same as impact-rated Class 4 shingles. Make sure the proposal specifies the exact product name and model — not just “architectural shingles.”

Ask about ventilation. Improper attic ventilation is the leading cause of premature shingle failure. A proper replacement includes a ventilation audit and, if needed, soffit and ridge vent upgrades. If a contractor doesn’t mention ventilation, that’s a red flag.

Get a written warranty with terms. Verbal warranty promises are worth nothing. Get the workmanship warranty in writing: term, what’s covered, the claims process, and who backs it if the company goes out of business.

References from Stillwater or Washington County. Ask for three local residential references. Stillwater’s historic homes are specific enough that you want to know the contractor has done similar work — not just standard ranch replacements — in this market.

Asphalt Shingles Deep Dive: 3-Tab, Architectural, Luxury & Impact-Rated

Understanding the four asphalt shingle categories helps Stillwater homeowners match product to budget, climate, and architectural context.

3-Tab Shingles

Three-tab shingles are the original modern asphalt shingle — a single-layer product with uniform rectangular cutouts that create the visual of three separate tab shingles. They’re the thinnest and lightest asphalt shingle category. Three-tab shingles are largely obsolete for new installations in Minnesota: their wind resistance (typically rated to 60 mph) is inadequate for Washington County’s documented wind events, and their lifespan in Minnesota’s freeze-thaw climate is typically 15–20 years rather than the rated 25 years. Most quality roofers no longer recommend 3-tab for new installations.

For Stillwater: 3-tab is not appropriate for Stillwater’s historic district, where period-appropriate profiles require at minimum a dimensional product. Not recommended for any new installation.

Architectural (Dimensional) Shingles

Architectural shingles are the current residential standard. A two-layer laminated product, architectural shingles create a dimensional, textured surface that resembles wood shake or slate at a fraction of the cost. Most are rated to 110–130 mph wind resistance and carry 30-year to lifetime limited warranties. Leading products:

• GAF Timberline HDZ (gaf.com): North America’s best-selling shingle, with StainGuard Plus algae protection, LayerLock technology for superior wind resistance, and a Lifetime limited warranty. Available in 30+ color options.
• Owens Corning Duration (owenscorning.com): SureNail Technology provides enhanced fastening zone; Lifetime limited warranty; excellent algae resistance.
• CertainTeed Landmark (certainteed.com): StreakFighter algae protection; SureStart Plus warranty; strong Minnesota presence through CertainTeed’s distributor network.

For most Stillwater residential applications — including mid-century ranches, 1990s–2000s colonials in newer neighborhoods, and standard two-story homes on the South Hill — a premium Lifetime architectural shingle is the right specification.

Luxury (Premium) Shingles

Luxury shingles are the highest tier of asphalt shingle, engineered to replicate the appearance of natural slate or wood shake at a cost roughly 50–100% above standard architectural. For Stillwater’s historic district, luxury shingles are often the architecturally appropriate choice.

• GAF Timberline UHDZ (Ultra HD): Thicker, more dramatically dimensional than standard HDZ; most closely approximates natural slate profile.
• CertainTeed Grand Manor / Presidential Shake: Popular for Victorian and Queen Anne-style homes; the Presidential Shake profile is explicitly designed for historic-style applications.
• Owens Corning Duration Premium: Enhanced dimensional depth with complementary colors for complex roof planes.

Heritage Preservation Commission note: For Stillwater properties in historic districts, luxury shingle color and profile selection may require HPC compatibility review. Sellers’ team can guide homeowners through this process.

Impact-Rated (Class 4) Shingles

Class 4 impact-rated shingles are tested per UL 2218 — a steel ball-drop test that simulates hail impact. Class 4 is the highest rating. These shingles use modified SBS rubber or fiberglass mat technologies to resist cracking and bruising from hailstones up to 2 inches in diameter.

• Malarkey Vista AR (malarkeyroofing.com): Class 4 UL 2218 rated; rubberized asphalt for impact resistance; NEX polymer modified for flexibility in cold temps; excellent Minnesota track record.
• GAF Timberline CS (Camelot Shingles): Heavyweight luxury product with Class 4 rating.
• Owens Corning TruDefinition Duration STORM: Class 4 rated with enhanced wind resistance.
• CertainTeed Landmark IR: Class 4 rated with embedded copper granules for algae resistance.

Insurance premium consideration: Many Minnesota carriers offer 20–30% premium discounts on homeowners policies for Class 4 shingles. For a Stillwater home paying $1,800/year in homeowners insurance, a 25% discount represents $450/year — enough to pay back the shingle upgrade premium in 3–5 years.

Ventilation: The Silent Variable

No shingle product, regardless of price or manufacturer warranty, performs as rated without proper attic ventilation. The principle: cold outside air enters through soffit vents, flows up through the attic space, and exits through ridge vents. This airflow keeps the attic at or near outside temperature, preventing: (1) ice dam formation from warm attic air melting roof snow in winter, and (2) heat buildup that accelerates shingle aging in summer.

Minnesota’s cold climate creates a specific challenge: vapor drive pushes interior moisture into the attic space in winter. Without adequate exhaust ventilation, this moisture condenses on the cold underside of the roof deck, degrading the deck over time and creating conditions for mold growth. The 1:150 or 1:300 net free area ventilation ratios required by Minnesota building code are minimums — not optimal targets. Sellers’ residential scopes include a ventilation audit and upgrade if needed.

Stillwater Homes and Minnesota Climate Considerations

Stillwater’s residential housing stock is more architecturally varied than almost any other city in the Twin Cities metro. Understanding that variation helps homeowners and contractors match the right roofing approach to the right property.

Historic core neighborhoods. The Laurel Street, Third Street, and Chestnut Street residential blocks in Stillwater’s historic district contain some of Minnesota’s finest Victorian, Queen Anne, and Craftsman-era homes. These properties often have 10/12 to 14/12 roof pitches, multiple dormers, complex valley intersections, and original wood or slate roof decks beneath multiple generations of re-roofing. Working on these homes requires: steep-slope safety protocols, experience cutting into historic deck assemblies, HPC-compatible material selection, and the flashing fabrication skills to create custom terminations at brick chimneys, decorative wood eaves, and ornamental ridge caps.

South Hill residential. South Hill neighborhoods between Greeley Street and the western city limits feature a mix of mid-century and 1970s–1990s residential construction — more conventional 5/12 to 8/12 pitches with standard rectangular footprints. These homes are currently cycling through their second or third major roof replacement and are strong candidates for impact-rated architectural shingle upgrades.

Millbrook, Liberty on the Lake, Legends. Stillwater’s western growth areas contain the city’s newest housing stock — 2000s to 2010s construction. Many of these homes are now at 15–20 years, when builder-grade shingles typically show granule loss, storm damage sensitivity, and seal strip failure. The most common replacement scenario is a standard 3,000–4,500 SF house with standard 6/12 to 8/12 pitch — straightforward work for an experienced contractor, but worth upgrading to premium architectural or impact-rated shingles rather than replacing like-for-like with a 30-year economy product.

Washington County climate reality. Per the NOAA Storm Events Database, Washington County has recorded multiple hail events producing 1-inch or larger hailstones in recent storm seasons. Minnesota’s spring storm season runs March through October, with the most severe hail events concentrated in May–August. The MN Climatology Office documents Washington County’s wind exposure as well — gusts exceeding 60 mph are not unusual during thunderstorm events, which argues for shingles rated to at minimum 110 mph wind resistance and ideally 130 mph.

Ice dams are a particular concern for Stillwater’s steep-pitched historic homes. The combination of steep pitch, architectural complexity, and the interior heat escaping through older insulation creates ideal ice dam conditions. Properly installed Ice & Water Shield and a ventilation upgrade are not optional add-ons for historic Stillwater homes — they’re essential components of a roof system that will perform through Minnesota’s winters.

Asphalt Shingle Roofing Costs in Stillwater (2026)

Asphalt shingle replacement costs in Stillwater track closely with the Twin Cities residential market, with modest premiums for steep-pitch and historic-district complexity. Here are realistic 2026 ranges:

Cost factors specific to Stillwater:

• Steep pitch premium: Homes above 8/12 pitch typically add $0.50–$1.50/SF to installation cost due to safety equipment requirements and reduced installation speed. Historic homes at 12/12+ pitch may add $2.00–$3.50/SF.
• Historic-district complexity: Custom flashing fabrication at ornate chimneys, dormers, and decorative elements adds $500–$2,500 to a typical historic-home project.
• Tear-off layers: Each additional layer of existing shingles (some Stillwater homes have 2–3 layers) adds $75–$150 per square to tear-off cost.
• Deck repair: Pre-1970 homes with original wood plank decks often require partial deck replacement; budget $60–$90 per sheet of OSB installed as needed.
• Ventilation upgrades: If soffit and ridge vent improvement is needed, add $800–$2,500 depending on scope.

For most Stillwater homeowners: A typical 2,500–3,200 SF two-story home with standard pitch runs $15,000–$22,000 fully installed with premium Lifetime architectural shingles. A historic-district Victorian at similar size with complex geometry and full flashing replacement may run $20,000–$32,000.

Process: What to Expect on a Shingle Roof Replacement

A residential roof replacement with Sellers Roofing follows a clear, homeowner-friendly process:

1. Free inspection and estimate. Sellers schedules a roof inspection at your convenience. The inspection covers shingle condition, flashing assessment, ventilation review, gutter condition, and deck spot-check. The written estimate specifies exact product (brand, model, color), all components (Ice & Water Shield, underlayment, drip edge, ridge cap, ventilation), tear-off scope, and warranty terms.

2. Proposal review and contract. You review the written proposal with no high-pressure close. Questions are answered in detail. Contract is signed; materials are ordered.

3. Pre-construction communication. You receive a confirmed start date, a description of what to expect each day, and a checklist of how to prepare (moving vehicles, protecting outdoor furniture, notifying neighbors if dumpster placement will affect street access).

4. Tear-off. Existing shingles and underlayment are removed. The deck is inspected; any damaged sheathing is identified and discussed with you before repair. Magnetic nail sweeps are used in the yard and driveway before debris removal.

5. Installation. Ice & Water Shield is applied at all eaves and valleys. Synthetic underlayment is installed over the full deck. Drip edge is installed at eaves and rakes. Shingles are installed per manufacturer specifications including correct nail pattern and placement. Ridge cap and ventilation are completed.

6. Cleanup and final inspection. Thorough cleanup including additional magnetic sweeps. Final walk-through with the project manager. Warranty documentation provided including both Sellers’ workmanship warranty and manufacturer warranty certificate.

7. Same-day callback. If you have any concern after the project is complete, call (651) 703-2336 — you’ll receive a same-day callback from Sellers’ team.

Frequently Asked Questions

Get a Free Asphalt Shingle Estimate in Stillwater

Stillwater’s homes deserve a roofer who understands the city’s unique architectural character, Washington County’s climate realities, and the installation quality standards that make a roof last 30+ years rather than 15.

Sellers Roofing Company is ready to inspect your Stillwater home, recommend the right shingle system for your property’s style and exposure, and deliver a fully written estimate with warranty documentation.

Call today: (651) 703-2336

We guarantee a same-day callback on every call. No voicemail loops, no waiting days for a response — you hear from us the same day.

You can also submit a request online at roofingexpertsstpaul.com.

Sellers Roofing Company
801 Transfer Rd, Unit 05, Saint Paul, MN (Midway)
Phone: (651) 703-2336
Website: roofingexpertsstpaul.com
Founded: 2017 | MBE • DBE • BBB A+ | Roofers Local 96 • Carpenters Local 322 • Laborers Local 563
4.8★ / 49 Google Reviews | 801+ Residential Projects Completed